Skip to main content
Tony's NY Pizza logo top - HomepageTony's NY Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • (239)-362-0604
  • jamesduff897@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Tony's NY Pizza logo top - HomepageTony's NY Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Catering Menu

Appetizers & Soup

Meatballs & Ricotta

$11.95
Two meatballs served with our homemade sauce and topped with ricotta cheese.

Fried Mozzarella

$10.50/5 pcs
Fried mozzarella served with marinara sauce.

Chicken WIngs

$14.99/10 pcs
Wings served with blue cheese • Hot | Mild | BBQ | Lemon Pepper | Teriyaki | Garlic Parmesan | Plain

Garlic Knots

$6.50/8 Pcs
Garlic knots served with marinara sauce.

Caprese Plate

$11.50
Fresh tomato, buffalo mozzarella, roasted red peppers, fresh basil, olive oil and balsamic reduction.

Eggplant Tower

$11.99
Hand breaded eggplant stacked with fresh tomato, buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and finished with balsamic reduction.

Soup of Day

$5.50

Boneless Wings

$14.99/10pc
Boneless Wings served with blue cheese • Hot | Mild | BBQ | Lemon Pepper | Teriyaki | Garlic Parmesan | Plain

Salads

Garden Salad

$10.95
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, roasted peppers, shredded carrot, olives, and onion.

Caesar Salad

$11.50
Romaine lettuce, croutons, and shredded Romano cheese | Add Breaded Chicken Cutlet +$4.95

Athens Salad

$13.50
Feta, black and green olives, onion, tomato, cucumber, and banana peppers, served over lettuce and served with a herb vinaigrette.

Antipasto Salad

$14.95
Romaine, lettuce, genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, buffalo mozzarella, tomato, cucumber, carrot, roasted red peppers, and olives, served with our house vinaigrette.

Calzones & Stromboli

Add any topping: Pizza +$1.49 | Specialty +$2.29

Stromboli

$14.99
Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions, mozzarella.

Cheese Calzone

$13.95
Mozzarella, ricotta, Romano, garlic, fresh herbs.

Create a Pie

Toppings $2.29 | $3.99: Bacon | Banana Pepper | Basil | Black Olives | Extra Cheese | Garlic | Green Olive | Ham | Jalapeño | Meatball | Mushrooms | Onions | Pepperoni | Peppers | Pineapple | Ricotta | Roasted Red Pepper | Sausage | Spinach | Tomato | Chicken | Eggplant | Anchovies

Medium Cheese Pie

$16.95/14"

Large Cheese Pie

$18.95/16"

Extra Large Cheese Pie

$20.95/18"

Sicilian Thick Pan Pizza (One Size)

$21.95

Personal Size Gluten Free Pizza

$14.95

Tonys New York Pies

The Brooklyn Meat

$25.00/+
M $25 | L $27 | XL $29 | S $30 • Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, ham, and bacon.

The Staten Island

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Sausage, peppers, onion, and mushrooms.

The Manhattan Deluxe

$26.00/+
M $26 | L $28 | XL $30 | S $31 • Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion, peppers, bacon, meatball, ham, olives, garlic.

The Queens White

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, Romano, olive oil & fresh herbs.

The Madison Square Garden

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Spinach, onion, pepper, mushroom, garlic.

The 5th. Ave. Mushroom

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Buffalo mozzarella, mushrooms, garlic, tomato, fresh basil and finished with a balsamic reduction.

The Park Ave. Margherita

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Plum tomato sauce, buffalo mozzarella, Romano, fresh basil, and olive oil.

The Grand Central Eggplant

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Eggplant, ricotta, basil and extra sauce.

The Greenwich Hawaiian

$23.00/+
M $23 | L $25 | XL $27 | S $28 • Ham, pineapple, and bacon.

The Buffalo Bill

$24.00/+
M $24 | L $26 | XL $28 | S $29 • Boneless buffalo chicken, mild buffalo sauce, Romano, mozzarella, and ranch dressing.

Philly Cheesesteak PIzza

$26.00/M
$28.00/L
$30.00/XL
Topped with Thinly sliced Steak,Green peppers, Onions ans Provolone

Pizza by The Slice

Cheese Slice

$3.75

One Topping Slice

$4.00

Gourmet Slice

$4.75

Classic Italian Subs

All Subs Served on a 12” Hoagie Roll | Add Fries for +$2.00

Meatball Parmesan

$13.95
Meatballs, marinara, and mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Parmesan

$13.95
Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara, and mozzarella cheese.

Eggplant Parmesan

$13.95
Eggplant, marinara, and mozzarella cheese.

Italian Combo

$13.95
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and roasted red peppers, topped with a herb vinaigrette.

Sausage Pepper & Onions

$13.95
Sausage, peppers, and onions topped with light tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Philly Cheesesteak

$13.95
Thinly sliced Steak, Onions, Peppers and Provolone

Italian Dinners

Served with your choice of a Small House or Caesar Salad • Dressings: House | Bleu Cheese | Ranch | Caesar

Spaghetti and Meatballs

$16.95
Spaghetti and two meatballs topped with our marinara sauce.

Lasagna

$17.95
Pasta layered meatball, sausage, ricotta, Romano and mozzarella cheese.

Baked Ziti

$16.95
Ziti, mozzarella, ricotta, Romano, and marinara.

Chicken Parmesan

$17.95
Chicken coated with bread crumbs, sauteed and topped with our marinara sauce, Romano and mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of Spaghetti or Penne.

Eggplant Parmesan

$17.95
Eggplant coated with bread crumbs, sauteed and topped with our marinara sauce, Romano and mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of Spaghetti and Penne.

Spaghetti and Sausage

$16.95
Mild Italian sausage served over spaghetti and topped with marinara sauce.

Sides

Fries

$3.50

Garden Salad

$5.95

Caesar Salad

$5.95

Meatballs

$4.95/2

Italian Sausage

$4.95/2

Extra Dressing

$0.99

Extra Marinara

$0.99

Dessert

Cannoli

$5.50

Tiramisu

$6.50

Zeppoli

$6.50

Cheesecake

$6.50

Cherry Cheesecake

$6.95

Blueberry Cheesecake

$6.95

Brownie

$6.95

Catering

1/2 Knots

$13.00/20 Pcs

Full Knots

$24.00/40 Pcs

1/2 Garden Salad

$50.00

Full Garden Salad

$95.00

1/2 Greek Salad

$55.00

Full Greek Salad

$100.00

1/2 Anti Pasto Salad

$65.00

Full Anti Pasto Salad

$105.00

1/2 Ceaser Salad

$50.00

Full Ceaser Salad

$95.00

1/2 Sausage Peppers Onions

$65.00

Full Sausage Peppers Onions

$105.00

1/2 Meatballs

$45.00/20 Pcs

Full Meatballs

$90.00/40 Pcs

1/2 Eggplant Parmigana

$80.00

Full Eggplant Parmigana

$150.00

1/2 Chicken Parmigana

$90.00

Full Chicken Parmigana

$170.00

1/2 Lasagna

$80.00

Full Lasagna

$150.00

1/2 Baked Ziti

$80.00

Full Baked Ziti

$150.00

1/2 Penne With Marianra

$65.00

Full Penne With Marianra

$105.00
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs